
The Cartoon Trial : We support Charlie Hebdo and the right to criticize any and all religions
The trial which is about to take place before the Paris Civil Court February on 7th and 8th is of the utmost importance. Charlie Hebdo is being prosecuted for having republished the twelve Danish cartoons on Mahomet that first appeared in the Jyllands-Posten.
In a context in which fundamentalists have been issuing death threats against anyone who dared support whatever news publications and whatever countries they have targeted, this newspaper has chosen to remain faithful to its tradition of freedom of expression and freedom of tone in regard to all religions and all their symbols: the pope as well as Mahomet.
It did so by making these twelve drawings available to the public at large, so that people could form their own opinion. So as not to yield to the demands of the fundamentalists.
As an act of solidarity with Jacques Lefranc, the editor-in-chief of France Soir, who had just been fired for having had the courage to refuse such demands. Because if all European news publications had done the same, the extremists' intimidations would have failed. Because if all European news publications had bowed to this injunction, their silence would have sealed the extremists' victory.
In spite of this climate, traditional Moslem organizations (the Paris Mosque), fundamentalist organizations (the UOIF : Union of Islamic Organizations of France) and even a major financial sponsor of Wahhabite extremism situated in Saudi Arabia (the Islamic League), chose to add a judicial threat to this intimidation by taking Charlie Hebdo to court, on the basis of anti-racist laws, for «public insult in regard to a group of persons by reason of their religion».
Two drawings are targeted: one showing Mahomet with a bomb in his turban, but also one in which Mahomet holds back a group of kamikazes by announcing: «Stop, there are no more virgins left.» The cover of the issue for which Cabu drew a picture of Mahomet who, «outdone by the fundamentalists», disavows them («It's tough to be loved by idiots») was also accused of being «injurious», whereas the purpose was to show a Mahomet who took exception to the extremists.
Which goes to show the sort of confusion encouraged by this accusation against a journal that has always fought against both racism and fundamentalism. We refuse the amalgam which - relying on an abusive use of the term «Islamophobia» - consists of equating legitimate criticism of Islamist extremism and of terrorism that makes use of Islamic symbols with racist attacks on individuals of the Muslim faith.
Some people say that today's geopolitical context should incite one to be prudent, even to keep silent. Quite the contrary. Freedom of expression and secularism need to be reasserted as never before. Those who resist fundamentalism have nothing but pen and pencil to counter threats. Democrats throughout the world, and in particular Moslem democrats, hope to find in Europe, and above all in France, a secular haven where neither dictatorship nor fundamentalism obstruct their freedom of speech.
If Charlie Hebdo were to be condemned, if self-censorship spread to become the standard legal precedent, we would all of us lose this common ground for resistance and liberty.
For these reasons, we support Charlie Hebdo and the right to keep on criticizing all religions without exception.
Deprecated: Non-static method dt::str() should not be called statically, assuming $this from incompatible context in /home/clients/1d242f8790072fdd395c365899072091/web/cgi/blog/inc/classes/class.blogpost.php on line 113
Strict Standards: Non-static method dt::_callback() should not be called statically in /home/clients/1d242f8790072fdd395c365899072091/web/cgi/blog/inc/libs/lib.date.php on line 35
Strict Standards: Non-static method dt::_callback() should not be called statically in /home/clients/1d242f8790072fdd395c365899072091/web/cgi/blog/inc/libs/lib.date.php on line 35
Strict Standards: Non-static method dt::_callback() should not be called statically in /home/clients/1d242f8790072fdd395c365899072091/web/cgi/blog/inc/libs/lib.date.php on line 35
lundi 5 février 2007
Signatures : Taslima Nasrin (écrivaine), Elisabeth Badinter (philosophe), Nasser Khader (député du Danemark), Ibrahim Ramadan (secrétaire générale de l'Association des musulmans démocrates danois), Irshad Manji (écrivaine), Albert Memmi (écrivain), Claude Lanzmann et le comité de rédaction des Temps modernes, Chris Marker (réalisateur), René Pétillon (dessinateur), Angelo Rinaldi (écrivain, membre de l'Académie française), Elisabeth Roudinesco (historienne), Mohammed Sifaoui (journaliste réalisateur), Leïla Babès (sociologue), Elisabeth de Fontenay (philosophe), Abdelwahab Meddeb (écrivain), Bernard-Henri Lévy (philosophe), Fethi Benslama (psychanalyste), Chahla Chafiq (sociologue, écrivaine), Wassyla Tamzali (écrivaine), Farouk Mansouri (écrivain journaliste), Françoise Seligmann (présidente d'honneur de la Ligue des droits de l'homme), Antoine Spire (journaliste), Michel del Castillo (écrivain), Yves Pouliquen (membre de l'Académie française et de l'Académie des sciences), Jean-Claude Pecker (professeur honoraire au Collège de France, membre de l'Académie des sciences), Frédéric Vitoux (écrivain, membre de l'Académie française), Jeanne Favret-Saada (directeur EPHE, section sciences religieuses), Pascal Bruckner (écrivain), Dominique Sopo (président de Sos Racisme), Jean-Michel Quillardet (grand maître du GODF), Gilles Perrault (écrivain), Patrick Gaubert (président de la Licra), Luce Perrot (présidente de l'association Lire la politique), Alain Girard (premier secrétaire général du SNJ), Bernard Teper (président de l'UFAL), Michel Zaoui (avocat), Alain Seksig (enseignant), Benjamin Abtan (président de l'UEJF), Nadja Ringart (sociologue), Ahmed Meguini (journaliste militant), Samia Messaoudi (journaliste Beur FM), Loubna Méliane (militante antiraciste), Nadia Amiri (infirmière), Jean-Marie Matisson (président du comité Laïcité République), Olivier Bétourné (éditeur), Christophe Girard (adjoint au maire de Paris chargé de la culture), Didier Idjadi (maire adjoint Verts à Bagnolet), Roland Castro (architecte, candidat à la présidentielle), Corinne Lepage (avocate, candidate à la présidentielle), Dominique Voynet (sénatrice, candidate à la présidentielle), Aurélie Filippetti (conseillère auprès de Ségolène Royale).
Associations signataires: SOS Racisme, LICRA, Grand Orient de France, Union des familles laïques (UFAL), Comité Laïcité République, Syndicat national des journalistes (SNJ).
Strict Standards: Non-static method dcMailer::sendToFriendLink() should not be called statically in /home/clients/1d242f8790072fdd395c365899072091/web/cgi/blog/themes/news/post.php on line 40
Strict Standards: Non-static method dcMailer::sendToFriendLink() should not be called statically in /home/clients/1d242f8790072fdd395c365899072091/web/cgi/blog/themes/news/post.php on line 41
Envoyer à un ami
- Lien permanent de cette news
Tag(s) associé(s) à ce billet :
Strict Standards: Non-static method twTags::show() should not be called statically in /home/clients/1d242f8790072fdd395c365899072091/web/cgi/blog/themes/news/post.php on line 56
Strict Standards: Non-static method twPostMeta::field() should not be called statically in /home/clients/1d242f8790072fdd395c365899072091/web/cgi/blog/ecrire/tools/twtags/functions.php on line 81
Strict Standards: Non-static method twPostMeta::get() should not be called statically in /home/clients/1d242f8790072fdd395c365899072091/web/cgi/blog/ecrire/tools/twpostmeta/functions.php on line 337
Strict Standards: Non-static method twPostMeta::_retrieve() should not be called statically in /home/clients/1d242f8790072fdd395c365899072091/web/cgi/blog/ecrire/tools/twpostmeta/functions.php on line 141
Strict Standards: Non-static method twPostMeta::_getCache() should not be called statically in /home/clients/1d242f8790072fdd395c365899072091/web/cgi/blog/ecrire/tools/twpostmeta/functions.php on line 64
Strict Standards: Non-static method twPostMeta::_getCache() should not be called statically in /home/clients/1d242f8790072fdd395c365899072091/web/cgi/blog/ecrire/tools/twpostmeta/functions.php on line 142